2024: A Vintage of Purity and Finesse
The majority of Bordeaux’s 2024 vintage reports headline with the word “challenging.” While it was a difficult vintage, requiring grit and determination to produce commendable wines, 2024 is far from a write-off. We spent last week in Bordeaux tasting through the new vintage and speaking to the men and women working behind the scenes. Our conclusion was that ‘challenging’ is more a description of the obstacles faced by the châteaux teams, affecting their ability to produce the desired volume rather than the ability to produce quality wine. Already with an idea of pricing, we believe 2024 could well be the best value vintage Le Clos has offered En Primeur. One thing is certain: it will be the most accessibly-priced Bordeaux vintage on the market, offering wines that are enjoyable in their youth, yet still hold ageing potential.
Growing Season
The 2024 growing season was marked by a series of challenges that tested vineyard managers and winemakers. Though the timing of these weather events was far from ideal, coming at crucial points in the vines’ growth, the technology, expertise and sheer dogged determination of the winemakers allowed them to navigate these obstacles. In the end, while the season was tough, the grapes that emerged from the vineyards appeared to be in great health. Axel Marchand, professor at the Oenological Research Centre in Bordeaux and leading consultant to the Grand Cru Classés, stated “the ratio of quality in this vintage (le rapport qualité/millésime) is extraordinarily high.”
Spring
The above-average rainfall, concentrated in the winter months, left the water table saturated by the time budburst occurred in early April. While the vines began the season with strong growth, a sudden drop in temperatures later in April brought frost and hailstorms, causing localised damage and slowing vine development. Mildew pressure, arguably the biggest challenge for properties in 2024, emerged early, with signs appearing by late April, and it remained a serious threat throughout May and June. It was generally a bigger problem on clay soils, affecting more Merlot, especially on the Left Bank. Organic vineyards, accustomed to battling mildew, gained an advantage by treating early, before the cold snap weakened conventional chemical treatments. This allowed several organic properties to achieve yields comparable to or better than those of conventional vineyards.
Cool and wet conditions continued into May, causing uneven flowering and uneven ripening (coulure and millerandage), which affected yields, particularly for Merlot and younger vines. This disrupted the ripening process, delaying véraison until mid-August.
Summer
The months of July and August brought above-average temperatures and, in many cases, hydric stress, which accelerated ripening. It is worth noting that the commune of Pauillac, despite the very wet winter (48% above the 30-year average), ended the year 2% drier than in 2023. This balmy weather continued well into September, allowing for full ripeness both phenolic (colour and tannin) and physical (sugar).
Autumn and Harvest
A short spell of rain starting on September 20th, around the time of the Merlot harvest, gave rise to the first big decision: to pick with less than desirable ripeness or to delay and face the inevitable risk or rot. We found a few Merlot-dominant wines, especially second wines, that fell foul of this with green notes present. Those who waited were able to achieve full ripeness, and the Cabernet harvest in early October fared better. It was a season ot unpredictability, requiring careful vineyard management and sorting. Yields were generally lower than average, with many choosing to declassify, as much as 15% of the crop.
Winemaking
Winemaking in challenging vintages requires difficult decisions, starting with the harvest date. Those wanting to avoid the rains of the second half of September chose to pick, while others waited and managed botrytis on the sorting tables or through the use of optical sorters and density baths. Particular attention was given to extraction, favouring a long but soft approach to preserve only the highest quality tannins. Surprisingly, grapes entered many properties with tannin and colour levels similar to other highly respected vintages. Château Margaux noted that the 2024 IPT levels (a measure of colour and tannins) were higher than any vintage of the 1980s and, more impressively perhaps, on par with their highly acclaimed 2015 vintage. This is a data driven indicator that 2024 is clearly a structured vintage and not light as was initially perceived.
Results
Expectations from the trade for the 2024 vintage upon arrival were low, yet most have walked away upbeat and confident about finding their customers a great selection of delicious wines. The 2024s are characterised by purity, balance and tension, with modest alcohol levels of 12-13%. In heterogeneous years like 2024, it becomes essential to taste through and select individual châteaux and wines that excelled. Cooler vintages are usually favoured by the white grape varieties. 2024 provided the perfect conditions for an excellent white Bordeaux vintage.
The 2024 vintage is the product of immensely hard work and skilful decision-making. We are focusing on a tight selection of the best wines from the vintage. As our trip last week showed, tasting was essential, and Le Clos is well placed to advise you on your 2024 choices. Releases will come early this year. May will be an exceptionally busy month, and we expect the campaign to finish by the end of the first week of June. Our selection will be focused around the châteaux that overdelivered and merit cellaring, concentrated towards the top of the quality and pricing pyramid.
Oliver Dixon – Head of Fine Wine